vendredi 16 septembre 2011

The very reason why apes don't dance

an answer to : Rise of the Apes via Miracle Grow a Freakonomics guest post by Mark Changizi :
http://www.freakonomics.com/2011/09/14/rise-of-the-apes-via-miracle-grow/

Thanks for sharing your work and views. The idea you present has quite an original and convincing edge : culture is the direct consequence of an ape's life as perceived though an ape's senses, when given more brain capacity, rather than the product of specific genome design.

You should take into account that this process has been extensively described by a great deal of european anthropologists in the eighties, Edgard Morin being the one who made the most aknowledged synthesis of this current of thought (now we don't have the Christian politics over here and the "intelligent design" trauma to overcome, so we don't care as much as you do).

Furthermore, describing those two aspects (contextual interaction and brain capacity) is missing the most mysterious point : what incentive did we receive, during hominization, in order to reproduce the sounds and visions of our environment?

Today's apes ain't. They just imitate each other, and they don't dance, sing or draw.

So we have the detonator (contextual interaction), and the tons of semtex (brain capacity) but what incentive did pull the trigger in the first place. If we don't answer this to start with, the whole theory you present would leave us with the Rise of the Planet of the Parrots, right?

Morin adds a third element : the hand, coupled with the tool, that might have been a direct survival incentive (better fighters) and become a differentiator. As long as apes have the ability to learn such behaviors (but not to dance, read or play music in the sense we do) it is most probable that the use of tools that pulled the trigger.

"2001, a Space Oddyssey" (which did acheive, as a movie, a different kind of popularity) has the most stunning metaphor ever for this. Check it again here :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xd3-1tcOthg&feature=related

In reality, the process of using tools has been way more progressive than what Clarke and Kubrick depicted: the use of tools for extracting food from nuts, which is present in today's animal behavior, has been most probably a lot anterior to using tools for hunt.

What I can't explain to myself, though, is why our society tends to forget fully published and satisfying theories and rediscover them and republish them. Please tell me that I have neglected an old and fully satisfying pre-existing theory for that, which proposes applicable solutions I should have heard of...